WHERE DID ISLAM ORIGINATE: MECCA OR PETRA? | THE SACRED CITY

Cinemavixion Review

This documentary, 'The Sacred City,' delves into a fascinating and controversial re-evaluation of Islamic history, positing a radical new theory about the origins of the faith. Canadian historian Dan Gibson, as presented by director David Taylor, challenges conventional understanding by suggesting Petra, rather than Mecca, was the original Holy City. The film hinges on archaeological evidence, drawing a compelling contrast between Petra's established role as a significant trade hub and Mecca's historical narrative. While the premise is bold, the documentary serves as an intriguing starting point for viewers interested in exploring alternative perspectives on foundational religious history. It encourages critical thinking and a deeper engagement with the historical and geographical texts that shape our understanding of Islam's genesis.